OTIS‐MAGIE’S JOINING MARSH & MCLENNAN AGENCY
When did Otis‐Magie Insurance Agency become part of Marsh & McLennan Agency LLC (MMA)?
December 7, 2018.
Why did Otis‐Magie decide to sell?
After regularly being approached by larger agencies, Otis‐Magie’s leadership team (Tom, Rick and
Rhonda) decided it would be best if Otis‐Magie explored possibilities to ensure the company’s future,
while Otis‐Magie was on solid ground financially and operationally, and not actually for sale.
Consequently, with help from their advisors they spent six months analyzing and identifying the best
strategy for optimizing future growth of the firm. After careful thought, they determined that joining
MMA was the best option to meet their goals of retaining their operating model and leadership
structure, while providing optimal growth for employees and the firm. Under MMA’s decentralized
business model, Otis‐Magie Insurance Agency’s culture and commitment to the community will remain
Why did MMA choose Otis‐Magie Insurance Agency?
MMA only seeks quality firms, not those that are struggling or need to sell. MMA’s leadership was
attracted to Otis‐Magie’s 132‐year tradition, and strong reputation, along with its leadership, quality
employees, culture and dedication to customer service.
How will Otis‐Magie jobs be affected?
No positions will be lost directly due to this acquisition. The people, values and service platform are
what attracted MMA to Otis‐Magie, and Otis‐Magies plans to continue working with clients in the same
way as we always have. This is about growth, not consolidation and cost reduction.
QUESTIONS ABOUT WORKING WITH OTIS‐MAGIE
Will I still work with the same people?
Yes. Our service teams will not change due to this transaction.
How can I reach my account representatives?
The same way you always have. We’ll remain in our offices, and keep the same phone numbers, fax
numbers and email addresses.
Will our company name and logo change?
Because MMA respects the equity we have built into our name and brand, we will initially make only
slight modifications to our current logo and name to reflect our new relationship with MMA. Our new
name is Otis‐Magie Insurance Agency, a Marsh & McLennan Agency LLC company. We can still be
referred to, unofficially, as Otis‐Magie Insurance Agency. Over time, we will transition to the MMA logo
and branding and will be known as Marsh & McLennan Agency. These timing decisions will be made
responsibly by local and regional leadership in ways that minimize any disruption.
What kinds of operational changes can be expected?
Any business transaction requires some change, and this one will be no different. Ultimately, though,
the changes should be limited to our internal processes more than anything and clients shouldn’t notice
much different. We’ll continue operating in the same locations, account teams aren’t changing, and
contact information will remain the same.
What benefit will I see as an Otis‐Magie customer?
There will be tremendous benefits to our customers. Not only will we have the backing (and all that
comes with it, including expertise, knowledge, carrier access, marketplace strength, proprietary
products and industry‐leading technology platforms) of the leading insurance brokers in the world, but
you will also keep the personal relationships and connection with the agents in your community. In
short, you’ll gain access to world class resources delivered locally through people you know, trust and
who are vested in your community.
QUESTIONS ABOUT MARSH & MCLENNAN AGENCY (MMA)
What is MMA?
Marsh & McLennan Agency was created in 2008 as a separate operating subsidiary of Marsh LLC, the
world’s leading global insurance broker and risk management advisor, primarily to serve the property
and casualty and employee benefits needs of the middle market. Since November 2009, MMA has been
building its national platform by strategically partnering with high quality insurance and consulting firms
across the country.
MMA is headquartered in White Plains, New York. The New York office does not service any clients and
primarily serves as the corporate headquarters for all of its agency companies. MMA keeps a small
corporate staff to ensure the majority of decisions are made by the regional management teams.
Who runs MMA?
David Eslick is chairman and CEO of MMA. David has nearly 30 years of experience in the insurance
industry, most recently with USI Holdings, where he led USI’s expansion through acquisition over a fiveyear
period. You can read more about David Eslick at the MMA Website.
Bill Jeatran is president of MMA. Bill is well known across the industry, and was the founder of RJF
Agencies, which joined MMA in 2011. Following RJF’s acquisition, he led the upper Midwest region
before becoming MMA’s president.
Where is MMA headquartered?
MMA is headquartered in White Plains, New York. Its regional headquarters is in Minneapolis
How does MMA envision growing in the next few years?
MMA has been very public about its goal of building one of our industry’s preeminent national
organizations. MMA has made dozens of acquisitions since it began building its national platform in
November 2009, and is one of the largest insurance brokers in the United States with more than $1
billion in annual revenues. Continued growth will occur through additional acquisitions and an ongoing
focus on organic sales growth.
Their unique acquisition growth model ensures little disruption of operations at the regional level,
ensuring the integrity and culture of each agency remains intact, while at the same time building a
comprehensive and diverse national network.
What other companies have joined MMA?
Recent additions to MMA include J.W. Terrill in St. Louis, Cline Wood in Kansas City, MHBT, Inc., in Dallas
and Vézina in Montreal, Quebec. Over the past several years, some very prominent firms with national
notoriety have become part of MMA, including Barney & Barney, Senn Dunn and Seitlin.
The upper Midwest region includes agencies formerly known as RJF in Minneapolis, Security Insurance
Services in Milwaukee, Dawson Insurance in Fargo, McGraw Wentworth and Cambridge Property &
Casualty in Detroit, Liscomb Hood Mason in Duluth, MN, Howalt+McDowell in Sioux Falls, Haake and
Cline Wood in Kansas City, and J.W. Terrill in St. Louis.
Worker Compensation Questions
How does an insurance audit work?
At the beginning of a policy term, the payroll and/or sales figures are estimated. At the end of a policy term the insurance company will audit the payroll and/or sales numbers to ascertain what the actual figures payroll and/or sales figures were and will adjust the premium for that policy term accordingly.
Personal Auto Questions
Home Owner Questions
Why do I need to insure my home for its replacement cost if I don’t intend to rebuild or replace it?
A Homeowners policy requires that the dwelling be covered for at least 80% of what it would cost to replace it.